Honest AisleScan a pack. See the score.Sign in
All guides

A claim in a capsule · 4 min

Probiotic pills are not a yogurt

A live culture in food is a recipe you can scan. A billion-CFU bottle is a supplement with a warehouse behind it. We score the pack we can see.

Shop the Vitamins aisle

Food still wins

Yogurt with a short list, kefir, sauerkraut. You can see what you are eating. A capsule may help a specific strain after antibiotics — that is a clinician’s sentence, not an aisle one.

What we can score

Sweeteners in gummies, dyes, a ‘proprietary blend’. The CFU number on the front is not a score. If the gummy looks like candy, it scores like candy.

How to shop it

If your gut is loud, start with the emulsifier note and a week of short lists. Pills after that, with a name on the strain, not a cartoon.

The extras we mean

Keep reading